As a whole, Season 51 was a bit of an improvement over Season 50. The cameos were toned down slightly, there were a lot more experimental sketches, and the new cast members mostly acclimated themselves to the show pretty well. Emphasis on mostly.
But for every good thing this season had, it wasn’t perfect. I think I can narrow the major problems down to three things…
1. Focusing on tired veterans instead of the newbies
2. Weekend Update is still a mess
3. Waaaaay too much Trump cold opens
Repertory Players
Mikey Day: Back when I started reviewing, I thought Mikey was a consistent highlight. Nowadays, I feel like I’ve already seen everything he can do. Don’t get me wrong, he still surprised me here and there, but for the most part, it was an endless supply of overacting, humiliation, and just plain bad ideas. (Best moment: Pinwheel)
Andrew Dismukes: To me, one of this season’s biggest problems is the bizarre lack of Andrew. After the last two seasons saw him rise to the top of my favorites list, he inexplicably took a backseat in a lot of episodes. When we did get to see him, though, he was just as funny as ever. But I’d keep an eye on him in Season 52. Things aren’t looking so good for his future. (Best moment: Rasta Driver)
Chloe Fineman: Thank goodness I never have to talk about this untalented alien ever again. This year, she was barely a factor, and every time she actually did get focus was horrible as fuck (Snack Homiez, anyone?). But this year also revealed a darker side to Chloe that none of us would have ever known about until she decided to blab about it in a Vanity Fair interview. What happened? Well, she revealed that when she was volunteering at a summer camp a long time ago, she deliberately pulled down the pants of a young boy and exposed his privates to everyone. This disgusted her fellow cast members in the room, and the media was pretty mad too. I don’t know if this played a factor in her getting fired over the summer, but it wouldn’t surprise me. Anyway, Chloe Fineman blows. (Best moment: NONE!)
Marcello Hernandez: After endlessly shoving him down our throats in Season 50, this year saw a bit of a downturn in Marcello’s fortunes. There were several episodes where he barely showed up, which of course I liked, and then, when he did get focus, it was mostly for his usual repertoire of stereotypical Hispanic characters. (Best moment: his Sebastian Maniscalco impression)
James Austin Johnson: Yet again, James proves what a talented guy he is by carrying most of the season on his back. Even his Trump impression, while still repetitive as fuck, has been starting to make me laugh more often. Is it just a case of Stockholm Syndrome or am I really growing to like it? Who knows? (Best moment: Why is this always so hard for me to pick? I’ll go with Mechanical Bull because his singing is what made that piece work.)
Sarah Sherman: JAJ’s Season 47 cohort sadly didn’t have much of an improvement this season. She’s only been on the show for five seasons and she’s already become a pale shadow of what she used to be. I cannot stand the stupid, audience pandering Update commentaries she was often saddled with. The one time she did something different ended up being cut! Anyway, I only see Sarah getting worse in the future if they don’t allow her to go back to what she does best: freaking the Hell out of us. (Best moment: Auctioneers)
Kenan Thompson: Get the fuck off this show while you still have your dignity intact, man. That really hurts me to say about him, because he’s the one I’ve been following for most of my life. But what else am I supposed to say about a man who’s entering his 25th season???? At least Darrell Hammond knew when it was time for him to leave. (Best moment: Hey, I actually have something for him! His pastor character on Update was pretty good.)
Bowen Yang: He was only in half the season, but it was clear that his time in the spotlight was up. Aside from his final episode, he barely did anything. (Best moment: NONE!)
Featured Players
Tommy Brennan: Who’s that? Did someone named Tommy actually join the cast? Out of all the newbies, I feel like this is the one I know the least about, because he barely did anything. It says a lot about his biggest role in a sketch that I initially mistook him for that night’s host, Connor Storrie. (Best moment: His introductory commentary)
Jeremy Culhane: My favorite newbie by a long shot. He just seems like a really funny guy to be around, and his big roles really show that. He even managed to give Tucker Carlson some humanity, which is amazing. (Best moment: a tie between Free Sample and his Mr. On Blast character)
Ben Marshall: Ben was the one I was looking forward to the most out of all the newbies, but I’ve been somewhat disappointed by the results so far. There was a troubling trend of him being typecast in audience pandering sketches (like that awful gay Harry Potter thing and the tanning commentary), and I didn’t see a lot of the likability he had in the Please Don’t Destroy stuff. (Best moment: Tutoring the Cool Kid)
Ashley Padilla: Given how great her first season was, it’s a shock that they didn’t promote Ashley to repertory status, especially since she’s now the lead female of the cast with Heidi and Ego gone. Her airtime this season was insane, the kind of results you usually only see from someone in the sixth or seventh season of their tenure. And while her actual sketches were hit or miss this time around, she’s clearly got a lot of talent. Here’s hoping she’ll get even better in Season 52! (Best moment: Haircut)
Kam Patterson: Ehhhh, not the biggest fan of this guy, to be honest. He was just there for most of the season, then he suddenly started popping up on Update every other episode in the second half. I thought for sure he would get fired after this season, but surprisingly he stuck around: (Best moment: Michael Irvin commentary)
Veronika Slowikowska: This chick has some real talent! From what I understand, she was a pretty popular stand-up performer before she joined, and if that’s the case, then I’d love to see her get more roles like that in the next season! (Best moment: White Castle Drive-Thru)
Jane Wickline: Now here’s the biggest surprise of Season 51. After a frankly horrible debut season where she was barely a factor and only focused on lame songs, she suddenly started giving more of a shit this year. I’d mark the Cousin Planet film as the point where I started taking notice of her improvement, and then she solidified it with that excellent commentary in the Finn Wolfhard episode. Before this season, I couldn’t wait to see her get fired, but now I’m a hundred percent on her side! Here’s hoping Season 52 will be even better! (Best moment: Tamara commentary)
Colin Jost and Michael Che: While Michael Che was his usual anti-white people self, Colin’s airtime outside of Weekend Update exploded. Mostly this was because of his overused and unfunny Pete Hegseth “impression”, but he also kept popping up for no apparent reason in other sketches, such as Buzz in that awful Home Alone parody and as a pimp in that funeral sketch. Is this some kind of hazing routine meant to humiliate Colin for his seniority among the cast, or is it just some bizarre desire to be “famous” now that he has an A-list celebrity for a wife? Either way, I’m not laughing.
So what were the best and worst episodes this season?
Best episodes: Miles Teller/Brandi Carlile, Nikki Glaser/Sombr, Glen Powell/Olivia Dean, Finn Wolfhard/A$AP Rocky
Worst episodes: Bad Bunny/Doja Cat, Sabrina Carpenter, Josh O’Connor/Lily Allen, Ariana Grande/Cher, Ryan Gosling/Gorillaz, Harry Styles, Olivia Rodrigo
And now, my favorite part…ranking the sketches!
Best sketches: Parent-Teacher Conference (from Bad Bunny), Experienced Lawyer (from Poehler), Social Experiment (from Carpenter), Gone Without A Trace (from Teller), Two People Who Just Hooked Up (from Teller), Press Conference (from Teller), American Girl XL (from Glaser), Mechanical Bull (from Glaser), Sorority Meeting (from Glaser), Pinwheel (from Glaser), AI Photos (from Powell), I Miss My Ex’s Dad (from Powell), Haircut (from Powell), Free Sample (from McCarthy), A Helping Hand (from McCarthy), Cousin Planet (from McCarthy), Mochi (Cut), Espresso Martini (Cut), Boy Band (from Wolfhard), Tamara commentary (from Wolfhard), Guy’s Girl (from Wolfhard), Euphoria Writer (Cut), One Battle After Another Action Figures (from Taylor), Confidence Class (from Taylor), both On Blast commentaries (from Taylor and Ferrell), Blowing It (from Taylor), Mom’s Camera Roll (Cut), Monologue (from Skarsgård), Funny Boyfriend (from Skarsgård), The Gentleman’s Code (from Storrie), Tutoring the Cool Kid (from Storrie), Lies (from Gosling), White Castle Drive-Thru (from Styles), Words to Live By (from Black), Husbands (from Black), Simon’s Life (Cut), The Knowledge Hour (from Domingo), Prep School (from Domingo), My Room (from Rodrigo), Rasta Driver (from Rodrigo), Mom: The Movie (from Damon), Auctioneers (from Damon), Monologue (from Ferrell), Bobbin’s Sacrifice (from Ferrell)
Worst sketches: EVERY SINGLE COLD OPEN, K-Pop Demon Hunters (from Bad Bunny), Dobby the Elf commentary (from Bad Bunny), The Rudemans (from Poehler), Rhonda LaCenzo commentary (from Poehler), Theme Song Masterclass (from Poehler), Kel Squad (from Carpenter), both Snack Homiez sketches (from Carpenter and Wolfhard), Girlboss Seminar (from Carpenter), Surprise (from Carpenter), George Santos commentary (from Teller), Bob Army (from Powell), Drunk Raccoon commentary (from McCarthy), Homes for the Holidays (from McCarthy), Teaching Hospital (from O’Connor), Wizard of Oz (from O’Connor), Study Group (from O’Connor), Home Alone (from Grande), Black Santa (from Grande), Love is Blind: The Reunion (from Grande), Heated Wizardry (from Wolfhard), Gate Agents (from Taylor), Backstab Island (from Taylor), Immigrant Dad Talk Show (from Skarsgård), Mr. Fronzi (from Storrie), Monologue (from Gosling), Cyclops (from Gosling), Passing Notes (from Gosling), Goo Goo Man (from Gosling), Best Buy (from Styles), Harry For Him (from Styles), Kathy (from Black), Self-Defense (from Black), Grandpa’s Wake (from Domingo), Edge of Destiny (from Rodrigo), ShopTV (from Rodrigo), My Ex (from Rodrigo), Alix Earle and Alex Cooper commentary (from Rodrigo), Godzilla (from Damon), Kamikaze Dolphins commentary (from Damon), Post Op (from Ferrell), Mechanic (from Ferrell), The Nudemans (from Ferrell)